Home
  • About
    • Philosophy and our goals
    • Governance
    • Organisational structure
    • Patrons
    • Our Impact
    • Tasmania
    • Jobs
    • Search
    • Annual reports
  • Research
    • Research Papers
    • Sort by Author
    • Submissions
    • National Energy Emissions Audit
    • Community Resources
    • Climate & Energy Program
    • Accountability Project
  • In the News
    • Media Releases
    • Infographics
    • Opinion
    • Podcast
    • Videos
    • Our blog
    • Petitions
  • Contact
  • Events
  • Subscribe
  • Donate
    • Make a one off donation
    • Make a regular donation

On the wrong track: The case for abandoning the promised $7 billion subsidies to Australia's dirtiest coal-fired power stations

The Gillard Government is committed to introducing a price on carbon pollution by July 2012 however the details of the price, the sectors of the economy that will be covered by the scheme and the design features of the compensation package that is likely to accompany the carbon price are currently being negotiated by the Government, the Greens and the Independents involved in the Multi-Party Climate Change Committee (MPCCC). While the details of the compensation package are yet to be finalised, the Government has made it clear that its preferred starting point is the compensation arrangements proposed to accompany the Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme (CPRS).

The final version of the CPRS was negotiated between Malcolm Turnbull, the then Leader of the Opposition and the former Prime Minister, Kevin Rudd. In addition to substantial household compensation, the final version of the CPRS also included generous compensation to:

• Emission intensive trade exposed industries (EITEs) who would receive up to 94.5 per cent of the pollution permits they required for free

• Coal-fired power stations with particularly high levels of emissions were to be eligible for the Electricity Sector Assistance Scheme (ESAS) which would have provided an estimated $7.3 billion worth of free permits to Australia's dirtiest coal-fired power stations

• Coal mines with particularly high levels of methane emissions were to be eligible for the Coal Sector Assistance Scheme (CSAS) worth $1.5 billion

• Medium and large manufacturing and mining firms were eligible for $1.1 billion through the Transitional Electricity Cost Assistance Program.

The political compromise that represented the final version of the CPRS was described by the Government's own climate change adviser, Professor Ross Garnaut, as "one of the worst cases of public policy making" that he had ever seen. Just why a low point in Australian policy development should serve as the starting point for the latest round of carbon price negotiations has been left unsaid by the current Government.

This paper provides a detailed critique of one of the largest elements of the compensation arrangements proposed by Kevin Rudd and Malcolm Turnbull, the $7.3 billion ESAS scheme designed to assist the owners of Australia's dirtiest coal-fired power stations. Having described, and critiqued, the case for the provision of ESAS the paper then argues that the money saved from scrapping the ESAS scheme could make a substantial contribution to the provision of new investment in renewable energy in Australia. The principles for the provision of such funding to stimulate the further expansion of the Australian renewable energy industry are provided in the final section.

Type of Publication: 
Research
Section: 
Economy
Environment

Download Publication: 
PDF icon PB 27 On the wrong track_4.pdf

Author: 
Dr Richard Denniss
Posted on:
26 May 2011

>> Share this Page

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

.

The Australia Institute is the country’s most influential progressive think tank. We conduct research on a broad range of economic, social and environmental issues in order to inform public debate and bring greater accountability to the democratic process.

Sitemap:

  • About
  • Philosophy and our goals
  • Research
  • Opinion Pieces
  • In the News
  • Media Releases
  • Make a one off donation
  • Make a regular donation
  • Contact
  • Governance
  • Join mailing list

Other Initiatives

  • Centre for Future Work
  • The Australia Institute Tasmania
  • No New Coal Mines
  • Go Home On Time Day
  • Climate & Energy Program
  • The Australia Institute acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as First Australians and recognise their culture, history, diversity and their deep connection to the land.

    The team at The Australia Institute acknowledges that the Australian Capital Territory is Ngunnawal Country and pay our respects to Elders past and present.

  • Copyright The Australia Institute |
  • RSS feed |
  • Website Privacy Policy